“So, why do faculty get guaranteed lifetime employment? We staff don’t get tenure. Why should they?”

A fairly new and very committed staff member asked this question. That question made me think that there are lots of things that we don’t know about each other’s work and that sometimes it is important for us to know these things.

So, I thought I’d make a start with an answer in The Scroll.

First, tenure does not mean employment for life.

There are very specific conditions under which faculty may lose employment. These range from financial exigency to moral turpitude, aka depravity. Admittedly, fairly serious grounds. Why should the requirement for loss of tenure be so high? Because tenure is protection for one of the highest values of academic life – academic freedom. To fulfill our mission – in fact, the mission of any serious university – St. Thomas faculty must be able to address controversial, uncomfortable and unwieldy issues without fear for their jobs. Curricular activities and scholarly work are protected by the requirements of tenure. Threats are real. In the not too distant past, there was the Great Margarine Massacre. Economists at a well-respected state university with strong agricultural ties were fired for failing to support the nutritional superiority of butter over margarine. Horrors, they even suggested that laws requiring yellow dye for the pasty white margarine to be sold separately were in restraint of trade.

Another, oft-overlooked value of tenure is the mentorship that comes with it. Senior faculty are able to offer advice on teaching, scholarship and service without fear for their own positions. When I was a new faculty member, senior members of the economics department – Mary Supel, Dan Fairchild, Mo Selim – gave me desperately needed tips on my teaching techniques much to the benefit of our students! Those students and I are eternally grateful. I have tried in my turn to help newer faculty over the years. I now see those then newer faculty mentoring yet newer hires.

The same security in one’s position also allows departments to hire better than themselves. Every year the academic quality of the University is maintained and strengthened as current faculty pursue the best new colleagues possible.

There is a down side of tenure, too, but that’s for another day. This is the beginning of a glorious new fall semester, a time for appreciating only the values of academe. With the falling leaves, the crashing financial institutions, and a presidential election hanging on economic issues, the itch to be in the classroom is strong for an old economist.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About The Author

Related Posts

3 Responses

  1. Michael Bublitz, St Paul MN

    I read today’s blog about tenure with great interest because my Father, Gordon Bublitz, spent his entire career working in the Dairy Industry for forty years, first as a Creamery Operater/Manager and then as the Manager of Member Relations for MidAmerica Dairymen here in St. Paul. He was an advocate for Dairy Farmers all his life. He spent a lot of time and energy lobbying on behalf of the Butter Industry at the MN legislature and also in Washington DC. at the national level. Through watching my father as I was growing up I learned a lot about how the American/Minnesota Political system works. My Dad was a self educated man who grew up during the Great Depression and could not afford the cost of a College Education. He was drafted into the US Army Air Corps (Air Force) and spent most of WWII in Italy. After the War he came home, married my Mom, and went to work running his first Creamery in Fairfax, MN and making butter. As they say the rest is history. I wished he was still here because he would have really enjoyed reading this blog.
    Michael Bublitz
    St. Thomas class of 1969.

  2. James Heaney

    Hurrah! It is very gratifying to see a robust defense of tenure coming out of our administration. Extensive, secure tenure is vitally important to the the very *idea* of a university, and, from down here, it feels like sometimes the non-faculty forget that a functioning university’s resemblance to a business firm is superficial at best. Thanks, Ms. Alexander!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.